Using Social Proof to Increase Your Conversion Rate

If you're looking to boost your website's conversion rate, you may have heard of the powerful marketing tool known as social proof.

Social proof is all about leveraging the opinions and experiences of others to increase credibility and trust among potential customers and clients.

In this article, we'll take a deep dive into:

Why social proof should be in your marketing strategy
Social proof examples
Best practices
How it can benefit your agency

What is social proof?

Social proof refers to the idea that people are more likely to believe something is valuable or trustworthy when they see others vouching for it. A bit like herd mentality. This can take many forms, such as customer/user reviews, social media endorsements, or even expert recommendations.

Essentially, it's using the power of the crowd to influence the perception of your agency's brand.

For example, let's say you're looking to buy a new pair of running shoes. You come across two different options online, both of which have similar features and prices. However, one of the options has dozens of positive reviews from other runners, while the other has no reviews at all.

Which one are you more likely to choose?

Most likely, you'll go with the one that has the positive reviews, because you trust the collective opinion of other runners who have tried and tested the shoes.

Why social proof matters in marketing

Studies have shown that as many as 92% of consumers read online reviews before making a purchase, and that customer reviews are more trusted than brand-created content. And it works the same for service-based businesses - this means that social proof is vital for building trust and authority with potential clients.

If you don't add social proof to your website or social media profiles, it may hinder the chances of a client choosing your agency over another, so adding reviews and testimonials to your online marketing is a good shout!

But why exactly is social proof so important when it comes to marketing impact and buying decisions? Let's take a look at the psychology behind it.

The psychology behind social proof

Humans are social creatures, and we often look to others for cues on how to behave or think. When we see others endorsing a particular product or brand, we assume that it must be high-quality and trustworthy.

This is why social proof is such a powerful tool for persuasion and influencing purchase decisions.

In fact, social proof can be so powerful that it can even override our own personal preferences or beliefs.

For example, let's say you've always been a die-hard fan of one particular brand of sneakers. But then you see that all of your friends and favorite influencers are raving about a different brand. Despite your own personal loyalty to the first brand, you may find yourself swayed by the social influence of the second brand and decide to give it a try.

Types of social proof to boost your conversion rate

Client testimonials

One of the most common forms of social proof is client testimonials. These can be written reviews, video testimonials, or even social media posts. The key is to ensure that your testimonials are genuine and reflect the true experiences of your customers.

Influencer endorsements

If you have access to influencers in your industry, getting their endorsement of your service can be a great way to build social proof. Influencers have large followings and are seen as experts in their field, so being able to use influencer marketing to tap into their ready-made audience can increase your agency's credibility.

User-generated content

User-generated content (UGC) is any content created by your clients, such posts on social networks or photos. This type of content is great for building social proof because it shows real people using and enjoying your service.

While this could be useful for your agency, it's used often by brands to promote products through customer success stories.

For example, let's say you run a coffee shop. You could encourage your customers to post photos of themselves enjoying your coffee on social media, using a branded hashtag. You could then feature these photos on your website or social feeds, showing potential customers that real people love your coffee and enjoy spending time at your shop.

Social media mentions

If your agency has been mentioned by reputable sources on social media, whether it be a large following or a news publication, this is a strong form of social proof that you can leverage to increase your conversion rate.

For example, if your agency is featured in an industry publication, you could include a quote or excerpt from the article on your website or other marketing materials. It shows that your business is well-respected and has been recognized by others in your industry.

Case studies

Case studies are focused on specific, real-world examples of your service in action by actual users. They're powerful forms of social proof and are often highly detailed and demonstrate the benefits your offering can bring to the table.

Case studies are a common tactic used by digital agencies and are most likely to show the client's journey from before they employed your agency to where they are now. For example, how you have helped a company improve its online presence.

The story + customer quotes are a winning combo when it comes to social proof.

Trust seals and certifications

Trust seals and product certifications are symbols of legitimacy that can greatly increase trust among potential clients. These can include things like SSL certificates, industry affiliations, or even awards your agency has won.

On your website, you could include badges or logos from industry associations or awards you've won, which can demonstrate your expertise and authority in your field.

Implementing social proof on your website

Are you struggling to convert website visitors into clients? Your website is key when it comes to the psychological phenomenon of social proof, where people are influenced by the actions and opinions of others.

Choosing the right social proof for your business

When implementing social proof on your website, it's important to choose the right types of proof that will resonate with your audience. Take a look at your target clients and consider what might be most persuasive to them.

For example, current customer reviews and testimonials can be powerful social proof for e-commerce businesses, while case studies and client logos may be more effective for B2B companies.

Placement and design considerations

Where you place your social proof can significantly impact its effectiveness. Consider placing it prominently on your homepage or on key conversion pages. Additionally, design your social proof to be visually appealing and eye-catching. Use high-quality images and bold typography to draw attention to your social proof and make it stand out.

A/B testing social proof elements

Not sure which type of social proof will work best for your agency? Try out different types of social proof, placements, and designs to see what resonates most with your audience. A/B testing is an excellent way to determine which elements of social proof are most effective at boosting your conversion rate.

Tracking and measuring success

Once you've implemented social proof on your website, it's important to track and measure social proof statistics to see its impact on your business. Track your conversion rate, sales metrics, and other relevant data to see how your social proof is impacting your bottom line.

Then use this information to continually optimize your strategy and improve results.

By consistently monitoring and refining your social proof strategy, you can build a strong and trustworthy agency that attracts and converts more clients

Best practices for leveraging social proof

Keep it authentic and genuine

Above all, make sure your social proof is genuine and reflects the real experiences of your clients. Avoid using fake reviews or misleading testimonials, as this can massively damage trust and your reputation.

One way to ensure authenticity is to include a variety of client experiences, both positive and negative. This shows that you value transparency and honesty, and can also help potential clients make more informed decisions.

Update social proof regularly

Regularly adding fresh social proof to your website can help keep your audience engaged and show that your agency is active and relevant.

You can also use social proof to highlight new services, or to promote seasonal or limited-time offers. This can create a sense of urgency and encourage customers to take action.

Showcase a variety of social proof

Don't rely on just one type of social proof. Instead, showcase a variety of different forms to appeal to different customers and use cases.

For example, you could include reviews, case studies, blog posts social media mentions, or endorsements and posts from experts.

Use social proof in email marketing and ad Campaigns

Social proof isn't just for your website. Use it throughout your marketing campaigns, incorporating it into email marketing messages, email newsletters and ads to increase conversions and drive more sales.

You can also use social proof to personalize your marketing messages, by highlighting reviews or testimonials from clients who share similar demographics or interests. This can help create a stronger emotional connection with your audience.

Real-life examples of social proof in action

Successful social proof campaigns

One example of successful social proof can be seen in Amazon's product reviews. These reviews provide a wealth of information about individual products, giving potential buyers the information they need to make informed decisions. In addition, Amazon's "verified purchase" badge helps to further establish the authenticity of these reviews, increasing their credibility.

Another example of successful social proof can be found in the travel industry, where sites like TripAdvisor and Expedia rely heavily on user-generated content to drive bookings. By showcasing reviews and ratings from their customer base and real travelers, these sites are able to provide valuable insights into hotels, restaurants, and other travel-related businesses, helping potential customers make more informed decisions.

Lessons learned from top brands

Brands like Nike and Apple have successfully leveraged social proof to build trust and generate conversions. By using real customer testimonials and expert endorsements, these brands have been able to establish themselves as industry leaders. For example, Nike's "Just Do It" campaign has been incredibly successful in part because of its use of real athletes and their stories to inspire and motivate customers.

Similarly, Apple's "Shot on iPhone" campaign has been effective in part because it showcases the stunning photography that can be captured using the company's products. By featuring real photos taken by real people, Apple is able to demonstrate the quality and versatility of its products in a way that resonates with potential customers.

How to adapt these strategies for your business

While it's great to look to successful companies for inspiration, it's important to adapt their strategies to suit your own business's needs - especially as a service-based agency. It'll take experimentation to find out which types of social proof resonate most with your audience.

Ultimately, the key to successful social proof is to be authentic and transparent. Don't be afraid to showcase both positive and negative feedback, as this can help to establish your credibility and demonstrate your commitment to client satisfaction.

Agency social proof example

As an agency, showcasing social proof is a little bit different from brands, so here's how we do it at MixBloom as a white label social media agency:

There are lots of other agencies out there so one of the main ways we like to show potential clients that we're different from the rest is by displaying customer feedback on our website - we have a dedicated reviews page and also pop-ups on our website.

We're all about transparency so we show testimonial quotes, our TrustPilot rating and even get some of our customers to send us a video testimonial to present.

Check out our customer reviews to see for yourself!

And if you like what you see, and need a helping hand when it comes to social media content creation, try us out with no commitments with a 7-day free trial 😉

‍

Overcoming potential drawbacks of social proof

Dealing with negative reviews and feedback

Negative feedback can be difficult to deal with, but it's important to address it head-on. Respond to negative reviews in a timely and professional manner, and look for ways to improve your service based on client feedback.

Avoiding over-reliance on social proof

While social proof can be a powerful tool, it's important not to rely on it too heavily. Make sure you're still focusing on delivering high-quality services that will generate positive reviews and endorsements in the first place.

Ensuring your social proof stays relevant and fresh

Social proof can become outdated over time, so it's important to regularly review and update your website's social proof to ensure it's still effective. This can involve refreshing testimonials, adding new certification badges, or using different types of proof altogether.

Final thoughts

When it comes to increasing your conversion rate, social proof is a powerful tool that can't be ignored. By leveraging the opinions and experiences of others, you can build trust and credibility with potential clients, ultimately driving more sales and growing your business.